Is your comforter getting old and bedraggled? Then, it’s time to upgrade it and transform your bed back into that pleasant, cozy space you know and love. When it comes to comforters, there are plenty of different ones on the market, allowing you to pick and choose the right one that matches your sleep preferences, the season and your own preferred aesthetics. However, it isn’t easy to select the perfect one without first knowing more about the comforter itself, which is why we’re here to help.
I’m a sleep expert who has tested mattresses, sheets, pillows and bedding for years, so if you’re looking for assistance, you couldn’t find anyone better to help you upgrade. I’ve curated this list of the best comforters around, each with its own pros and cons that’ll make picking which speaks to you 100x easier. Read on to find out more.
What is the best comforter overall?
The Buffy Cloud comforter took the crown as the best comforter that I tested. I love it so much that I sleep with it every night. It’s ultra soft and fluffy and exudes luxury and comfort, elevating the look of any bedroom. It has a eucalyptus fabric shell and an eco-friendly, certified-recycled fill, making it lightweight and airy. It’s the type of comforter that just about anyone will like, and it’s also one of the most affordable comforters on this list.
Read more: Best Mattress of 2025
Best comforters for 2025
Our take: The Buffy Cloud comforter is a warmer, plusher pick. It’s perfect for cooler weather or all seasons if you don’t have any issues heating up at night. Even though I’m a hot sleeper, I’ve slept with this comforter for about a year now and don’t have any complaints (although, I do like to keep my room at a cooler temperature). I also sleep only with this comforter — no duvet cover, top sheet or other blankets.
How it sleeps: The outside shell of the Buffy Cloud is made with eucalyptus fabric, which offers a softer and more breathable option than cotton. While I wouldn’t say it’s cool to the touch, it is more temperature-regulating than other down alternative comforters. Inside the Buffy Cloud is a soft, eco-friendly, certified-recycled fiber fill that gives the comforter a fluffy, lightweight and airy feel. It’s an ultra-cozy addition to any bed. I would recommend a duvet cover since washing this huge, fluffy comforter can be a pain.
Pros:
- Plush and warm
- Soft and breathable eucalyptus fabric
- Eco-friendly bedding option
Cons:
- Not for people who want a down or a lighter comforter
- Fabric can snag if you machine-dry
Additional details:
- Fill: Recycled fiber
- Shell material: Eucalyptus fabric
- Sizes: Twin/Twin xl, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
- Care: Machine-washable
- Trial period: 50-night trial or 7-day free trial
Our take: The Rest Evercool Cooling comforter earned the top spot on my Best Cooling Comforters list. It’s one of the only comforters I’ve tested that’s truly cool to the touch thanks to its naturally cooling Tencel and Sorona materials. This is the best comforter for those who heat up during the night.
How it sleeps: This comforter is thin and looks more like a blanket than fluffy bedding. Due to its materials, such as Tencel lyocell, the Rest Evercool Cooling comforter is naturally moisture-wicking and will help to keep hot sleepers at a good temperature all night. My boyfriend and I practice the Scandinavian sleep method at night, so he sleeps with this comforter while I use the Buffy Cloud. Like me, he’s a hot sleeper and hasn’t had any problems with night sweats. It has also held up against our pets and many washes.
Pros:
- Best for hot sleepers or anyone who heats up at night
- Soft and very cool to the touch
- Available in six colors (three are reversible)
Cons:
- Stitching tends to pull after many washes
- Thin and wrinkles easily
- Not for cool sleepers or those who want a thick comforter
Additional details:
Our take: Budget bedding is usually made of low-cost materials with a cheap polyester feel, but this is not the case when it comes to the Quince Premium Down Alternative comforter. It looks and feels similar to other more expensive comforters on the market. With a 100% cotton sateen shell, you can’t beat the price and quality.
How it sleeps: The Quince comforter resembles a full-priced down comforter rather than a down alternative like the Buffy Cloud. It’s light, airy and on the thinner side, and the shell feels just like cotton covers found on down duvet inserts. The fill is microfiber but it doesn’t feel cheap. I tested the all-seasons fill option and the thickness is a happy medium for hot and colder weather. It also has corner loops if you decide to put a cover on it (which I recommend because washing might cause the fill to clump together).
Pros:
- You save about 50% compared to retail prices
- Three fill options: lightweight, all-season and ultra-warm
- Hypo-allergenic microfiber fill and soft 100% cotton sateen cover
Cons:
- Needs regular fluffing to keep fill even
- Stuffing may clump together after many washes
Additional details:
- Fill: Microfibers
- Shell material: 100% cotton sateen
- Sizes: Twin, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
- Care: Machine-wash
- Trial period: 365-night trial
Our take: For anyone who sleeps with a partner who kicks the blanket off while you’re freezing, consider the Create Your Perfect Comforter from Sleep Number. CNET sleep writer Taylor Leamey has been sleeping with this blanket for the last few months and is very impressed. Our sleep expert likes this customizable comforter so much that it received a 2024 CNET Editors’ Choice Award.
How it sleeps: The comforter is essentially two blankets joined by a zipper down the center. The zipper is under two fabric flaps, so you barely notice it’s there. Each person gets to choose how warm they want their side of the blanket to be. Leamey said, “During my years of testing blankets and bedding products, I haven’t encountered a comforter that is as customizable as the Create Your Perfect Comforter. Each person can choose between down and down alternative fills and three warmth options: light, medium and extra warmth.” The extra warmth version provides plenty of warmth while still being breathable.
Pros:
- Super comfortable
- Three warmth options
- Two fill options: down or down alternative
Cons:
- The zipper was stiff at first
- More expensive than other blankets
- Must add two halves to your cart to make a full comforter
Additional details:
- Fill: 100% down or 100% polyester
- Shell material: 100% cotton
- Sizes: Half-Queen or Half-King
- Care: Machine-washable
- Trial period: 100-night trial; 1-year
Our take: While most down comforters are only available in white and require a duvet cover for some color, the Garnet Hill Essential Down comforter is durable, well-made and available in a dozen beautiful, bold colors. This bedding is ready to be used right out of the packaging; no duvet is needed.
How it sleeps: There is only one weight available with this comforter: warm. While it isn’t as fluffy as the Buffy Cloud comforter, the premium, 100% cotton shell and down fill trap in your body heat. If you’re a hot sleeper, I would steer clear of this one, but it should work well for average sleepers and those looking for warmer winter bedding. The Garnet Hill Essential Down comforter isn’t as soft as others on this list, but if you’re a fan of down comforters, you’ll likely be a fan of this one.
Pros:
- Many colors to choose from
- 100% Responsible Down Standard certified down and Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified
- All-season fill
Cons:
- Not as soft and fluffy as other options on this list
- No corner loops if you want to use as an insert
Additional details:
- Fill: 100% Responsible Down Standard down
- Shell material: 100% cotton
- Sizes: Twin, Double/Queen, King/Cal King
- Care: Machine-washable
- Trial period: 90-day trial
Our take: Down alternative material is more affordable, hypoallergenic and eco-conscious than down. I find down alternative generally more comfortable since it’s loftier, softer and durable — also, these comforters tend to lose less filling over time. The Layla comforter is an ideal fluffy, down alternative bedding that you can throw right into the wash.
How it sleeps: Layla’s outside shell is 100% cotton, which gives it a soft feel right away. Unlike traditional down covers, this comforter feels like your favorite lightweight cotton sheets. The inside is filled with clusters of microfibers that are satiny and fluffy. It has a baffle box stitch construction in the shape of puffy octagons. I find that this keeps the filling from bunching in the corners. This comforter is a little heavier than the others I tested, so I wouldn’t recommend it to hot sleepers or for hot summer nights. It’s perfect for cozying up the rest of the year.
I like to use this comforter to cover my white bedding so my dogs can snuggle up in bed with me. While it has upheld too many washes to count, the color has faded over time.
Pros:
- Fluffy and comfortable
- Down alternative is more affordable and hypoallergenic
- Baffle box stitch keeps fill in place
Cons:
- Only available in white and a light gray
- Threading pulls and color fades after many, many washes
Additional details:
- Fill: Down alternative
- Shell material: 100% cotton
- Sizes: Twin/Twin xl, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
- Care: Machine-washable
- Trial period: 120-night trial
Our take: If you’re a hot sleeper or need a thin layer to add to your bedding, a lightweight comforter will do the trick. The Brooklinen Down comforter is truly an airy, fluffy comforter that won’t trap in too much heat or be too heavy on top of other blankets. It can be used as a duvet insert or a comforter on its own.
How it sleeps: The outer shell of this Brooklinen comforter is made of 100% cotton sateen. Its light, airy feel comes from the Downmark-Certified down clusters, sustainably sourced from Hutterite farms in Canada. It has a baffle box design that keeps the filling from shifting to one side of the blanket. If you want a heavier or warmer comforter, Brooklinen also offers all-season and ultra-warm options. While it’s only available in white, you can opt for a Luxe Sateen duvet cover, available in 16 colors.
Pros:
- Baffle box design keeps the fill in place
- Down is sustainably sourced from duck or geese living on Hutterite farms in Canada
- Three fill options: lightweight, all-season and ultra-warm
Cons:
- Not a budget choice
- Not the fluffiest option out there
Additional details:
- Fill: Down cluster
- Shell material: 100% cotton sateen
- Sizes: Twin/Twin xl, Full/Queen, King/Cal King
- Care: Dry-clean only
- Trial period: 365-night trial
Our take: The most luxurious bedding on this list in terms of look, feel and price goes to Cozy Earth’s bamboo viscose comforter. It’s made with 100% bamboo viscose, inside and out, which gives it a silky smooth feel. The material is lightweight and breathable and the comforter isn’t too thick, making it a great option for hot sleepers. I love how this comforter looks on my bed, and the silk satin material even shines a little in the light.
How it sleeps: Bamboo is a breathable material that’s great for hot weather and hot sleepers. It’s naturally moisture-wicking and soft — this Cozy Earth comforter feels like it was made of silk (which is also an option for about $150 more). It drapes over you without creating a microclimate of heat between you and the blanket, and the weight is just right. I also appreciate how Cozy Earth made it oversized; the comforter was able to fully cover my bed and drape evenly on both sides. It’s sure to elevate the look of anyone’s bedroom.
Pros:
- Luxurious look and feel
- Weight works for all seasons
- Great for hot sleepers
Cons:
- Only one color option
- Not a budget pick
Additional details:
- Fill: 100% viscose from bamboo
- Shell material: 100% viscose from bamboo
- Sizes: Twin, Full/Queen, King
- Care: Dry-clean recommended; machine-wash under specific care instructions
- Trial period: 100-night trial
How we tested the best comforters
At CNET, our sleep experts (myself included) have been testing mattresses and sleep products for years. From high-tech mattress accessories like the Eight Sleep Pod to cooling pillows, I’ve reviewed enough sleep products to know what’s worth the price and what’ll hold up over time.
I tested each comforter on this list for at least three weeks by sleeping with them, lounging around and thoroughly inspecting each one. I assessed every comforter based on its feel, material, fill, price, customization, care and trial period. I also considered how well each comforter would work for hot sleepers like myself. Some bedding, like the comforters from Buffy, Rest Evercool, Layla and Cozy Earth, I had for a year and still use today.
What to consider when choosing the best comforter
If you’re just starting your comforter-buying journey, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. Here are a few aspects to keep in mind when searching for the best comforter for you.
Material: How a comforter feels will largely depend on what it’s made from — both inside and out. In most cases, the shell material will be listed first, with the fill material often buried in the site description. The fill material is especially important to pay attention to if you have allergies. If that’s you, avoid materials like down; instead, look for a down alternative that’s both hypoallergenic and pillowy.
Other popular comforter materials include cotton, microfiber, polyester, wool and silk.
Fill power: Fill power is an industry term, limited to only down products. It refers to how much loft the comforter has. Fill power is a numerical value in the hundreds describing how many cubic inches the down can fill. In general, the higher the fill number, the better the quality and the fluffier the comforter will feel.
Construction: A comforter that’s made well will hold up longer than those cheaply constructed. We’ve all used comforters that seem fine when you look at them, but the filling has shifted into uneven clumps. Stitching patterns like the baffle box will help keep the fill in place and extend the life of your comforter. Look for extra threading around the edges and small stitching details, as these are also clues that a comforter has solid construction.
Price: Your budget is one of the most important things to remember when shopping for a comforter. Just like mattresses, comforters come at every price. While plenty are affordable at under $100, there are more luxury options if you’re ready to spend closer to $450.
Our CNET sleep experts found that the best brands of comforters include Buffy, Brooklinen, Rest, Quince, Garnet Hill, Cozy Earth, Layla and Sleep Number.
Budget comforters will cost under $100, starting at $50 on the low end. Your average comforter costs around $150 to $200; the best luxury comforters can go for $300 or more.
The best comforter materials include bamboo, silk, down, down alternative and cotton. Bamboo and silk are more breathable, while down and down alternatives are warmer and fluffier.
The main difference is that a comforter is one piece of bedding, while a duvet is both an insert and a cover. A comforter is a thick blanket used on its own and does not require a cover.
Well-made products always hold up better against the test of time. When shopping for comforters, look for threading around the edges and smaller details like the stitching pattern to ensure you get a well-constructed product. For example, a comforter with a baffle box pattern will keep the fill in place longer.
Add comment